
Key takeaways
Two trending series will correlate even when they are unrelated; always plot, test for stationarity and difference before modeling.
Estimating effects from time series means dealing with inflation, autocorrelation, slow adjustment and, hardest of all, endogeneity.
X "Granger-causes" Y if the past of X improves forecasts of Y. It is predictive causality, not the effect of an intervention.
A six-step procedure runs from plotting the series to impulse response functions; conclusions can change with the number of lags.
Anticipation and omitted variables create spurious Granger causality, so treat results as clues for where to experiment.
Does higher marketing spending raise profits, or do higher profits lead companies to spend more on marketing? To most managers the answer seems obvious: marketing drives sales, sales drive profit. But the reverse is just as plausible: many companies set the marketing budget as a percentage of revenue, so in good years they spend more. In a company's quarterly figures the two series move together, and a high correlation does not tell which direction is right.
Time-ordered data (weekly sales, monthly ad spend, daily prices) are the most common kind of data in business and also the most misleading. Two trends moving in the same direction over time are a classic trap that makes correlation look like causation. This article goes further: how to estimate effects from time series carefully, and what Granger causality, a widely used notion for judging which series "leads" which, can and cannot tell us. It draws mainly on the chapter on causality in time series in Haughton et al. (2026).
The article has six parts. Section 1 covers the trap of spurious correlation and the notion of stationarity. Section 2 works through an example estimating the effect of gasoline prices on sales, with the typical problems of time series. Section 3 introduces Granger causality, and Section 4 walks through six testing steps using gold and oil prices. Section 5 reviews business applications, including media mix modeling. Section 6 explains why Granger causality is not causality in the full sense.
1. Time series and the trap of spurious correlation
Before talking about causality, it helps to understand why time series produce spurious correlations more readily than any other kind of data. This section introduces stationarity and how to check for it.
1.1. Ohio beavers and Irish GDP
Haughton et al. (2026) offer an unforgettable example: over 1960–2019, the number of beaver colonies in Ohio and real GDP per capita in Ireland had a correlation of 0.88. There is no conceivable causal link between them, not even a plausible common cause. They correlate simply because both drift over time. As early as 1926, Yule (1926) asked why time series so often produce "nonsense correlations", and the answer is still the same: when two series both trend, they look related even when entirely independent.
1.2. Stationarity and differencing
A series is stationary when its mean and variability do not change over time: it fluctuates around a stable level rather than drifting up or down. A growing company's sales, the consumer price index and GDP are all non-stationary. The usual remedy is differencing: instead of comparing this month's sales level with this month's ad spend, compare the change in sales with the change in ad spend. When this is done for Ohio beavers and Irish GDP, the correlation disappears completely. For series that grow proportionally, differencing the logarithm gives growth rates, which are often easier to interpret.
The most common test of stationarity is the augmented Dickey-Fuller (ADF) test. If a series has a structural break (a pandemic changing shopping behavior, for example), other tests are more suitable. The practical rule is: always plot the series first, always check stationarity, and never regress one trending series on another without dealing with the trend.
2. Estimating the effect of price from time series
The first example in Haughton et al. (2026) is a pricing problem. A fuel company sells gasoline at $3.51 a gallon and wants to know what would happen if it raised the price. It has data since 2005 on its sales, regional GDP and population, a price index, its own gasoline price and a rival's diesel price. The example shows the typical problems of estimating effects from time series, summarized step by step below.
2.1. Preparing the data
Two adjustments are almost always necessary. The outcome should be sales per capita, to remove the effect of population growth. Prices and GDP should be converted to real terms (adjusted for inflation) at a base year, because $3 in 2005 and $3 in 2023 do not buy the same amount. Then plot the key series: the real prices of gasoline and diesel, real GDP per capita and gasoline sales per capita.
Next comes the causal assumption. Gasoline sales depend on income (GDP per capita), on the gasoline price (higher price, lower quantity, by the law of demand) and on the diesel price, a close substitute (when diesel is expensive, some drivers switch to gasoline cars). The crude oil price affects both gasoline and diesel prices, so it is a confounder that should be included to block the back-door path.
2.2. Autocorrelation and ways to deal with it
An ordinary linear regression fits reasonably well, with coefficients of the expected signs. But the Durbin-Watson statistic is well below 2, indicating autocorrelation in the residuals: a positive shock this year tends to be followed by another next year. With autocorrelation, p-values become too optimistic, meaning the model is more confident than it deserves to be. Autocorrelation often signals a missing variable or a wrong functional form.
Haughton et al. (2026) try several remedies, summarized in Table 1. Adding a time trend improves the fit but may "absorb" part of the effect that really belongs to income. A log-log model gives coefficients that are elasticities: the price elasticity of demand for gasoline is −0.097, so a 10% price rise reduces sales by about 1%. The Prais-Winsten method transforms the data to remove autocorrelation. A partial adjustment model lets consumers respond slowly: only about 28% of the adjustment happens within the first year, the short-run elasticity is −0.263 and the long-run elasticity is about −0.93 (the short-run elasticity divided by the speed of adjustment). Finally, because the gasoline price and GDP are non-stationary but share a long-run equilibrium with sales, an error correction model shows that if sales deviate from the long-run demand curve, about two-thirds of the gap closes within the first year.
The last row of Table 1 is the hardest. A higher price reduces purchases, but rising demand may also lead sellers to raise prices; the observed data are then the intersection of supply and demand, not the demand curve. Unless this endogeneity is addressed, every elasticity estimated above may be biased, however good the fit.
3. What is Granger causality?
The gasoline example starts from a causal assumption: price affects sales. Often we have no such assumption, as with the marketing and profit question at the start of this article. In 1969, the economist Clive Granger (later a Nobel laureate in economics in 2003) proposed an approach based on temporal order (Granger, 1969). This section explains the idea.
Suppose we want to know whether the oil price "causes" movements in the gold price. Step one is to forecast the gold price using only its own past values. Step two is to add past values of the oil price to the model. If adding past oil prices improves the forecast of gold in a statistically significant way, we say the oil price Granger-causes the gold price. The idea is that a cause cannot come after its effect, so if the past of X contains information that helps forecast Y, X may be one of Y's causes.
What must be clear from the outset is that this is a notion about forecasting, not about intervention. Many authors call it "predictive causality" to avoid confusion. We also usually test both directions: if X Granger-causes Y and Y also Granger-causes X, there is bidirectional Granger causality. With two variables, the model used to test both directions at once is the vector autoregression (VAR), in which each variable is forecast from its own past and the past of the other.
4. Six steps to test for Granger causality
Haughton et al. (2026) illustrate the procedure with daily gold prices (dollars per ounce) and oil prices (dollars per barrel) from 13 January 2015 to 1 November 2024, covering 2,441 days with both prices available. Figure 1 summarizes the six steps, discussed in turn below.

Step 1, plot the series. The gold price trends upward (partly because it is not adjusted for inflation), while the oil price fluctuates sharply with a spike and then a fall. Looking at the charts reveals trends, breaks and outliers before any test is run.
Step 2, check stationarity. The ADF test shows that neither price series is stationary, but their differences are. Differences of logarithms, that is, daily percentage changes, are also stationary and are used in the following steps.
Step 3, choose the lag length. You must decide how many periods back the model looks. Information criteria balance fit against parsimony, but they do not always agree: here the AIC suggests four lags while the BIC suggests none. The authors use two lags for illustration. Conclusions about Granger causality can change with the number of lags, so this is a step where sensitivity should be checked.
Step 4, estimate the VAR. The results show that a rise in the oil price is followed by a rise in the gold price the next day and a fall the day after, both significant at the 5% level. The gold price also affects the oil price with a lag of two trading days.
Step 5, test for Granger causality. The test asks: do lagged values of the other variable improve the model? Both directions reject the null hypothesis of "no causality", so there is bidirectional Granger causality between oil and gold prices.
Step 6, plot impulse response functions. Because a VAR is dynamic, a shock to one variable spills over to the other and then feeds back over several periods. An impulse response function shows how each variable responds over time to a unit shock in the other, with a 95% confidence band. This step is optional but shows how large the effect is and how long it lasts, information a p-value does not give.
The result can be drawn as a time-series causal diagram, as in Figure 2. Each variable appears at several points in time, and arrows only run from past to present. Haughton et al. (2026) remark that it might have been better to start rather than finish with this diagram, because it forces the analyst to think about structure before estimating.

5. Business applications
Granger causality is used heavily in macroeconomics, for example to examine whether consumption leads GDP or the reverse. In business, applications are less common but by no means rare. This section reviews three.
5.1. Marketing spending and profit
Back to the opening question. Banerjee and Siddhanta studied personal care companies in India using quarterly data from 2001 to 2011 (as cited in Haughton et al., 2026). The logarithms of profit and of marketing spending were non-stationary, but their differences were stationary. The AIC chose a lag of nine quarters, which makes sense because marketing may lower profit in the short run but raise it a year or two later. The two series were cointegrated, sharing a long-run equilibrium, so the VAR was extended to a vector error correction model. The result: marketing spending Granger-caused profit, with a lag of about one and a half to two years, while profit did not Granger-cause marketing spending. For the companies in the sample, the answer leaned towards "marketing creates profit".
5.2. Competitor reactions
Haughton et al. (2026) describe a consulting project in the telecoms industry that used weekly advertising spend to see whether one corporation's spending was followed by its main competitor's, or vice versa. If the competitor typically raises advertising a few weeks after the company does, the company needs to factor that reaction into its budget, because the sales it wins may be clawed back. Any industry with intense advertising competition, such as telecoms, digital wallets, food delivery or consumer goods, has a similar structure, provided competitors' spending can be obtained from media measurement firms.
5.3. Media mix modeling
The most common use of time series in marketing is media mix modeling (MMM): measuring the effect of spending on each channel (TV, social media, search, out-of-home) on sales in order to reallocate the budget. The standard technique is regression on weekly or monthly data. Haughton et al. (2026) point out three frequent weaknesses. First, short data: figures older than about five years may reflect a different market, so samples are small unless regional data exist. Second, pressure to find a good fit and significant coefficients leads to overfitting and "p-hacking". Third, the lack of data on competitors' spending, which affects one's own sales. The general reminder is that regression only measures association, so MMM results should be checked against experiments, such as switching a channel off or up in randomly chosen regions.
6. Why Granger causality is not causality
The name "Granger causality" invites misunderstanding. This section explains the conditions needed for a credible conclusion and the cases where it misleads.
6.1. Coming first is not causing
The familiar example: greeting card sales rise sharply a few weeks before Christmas, so card sales Granger-cause Christmas. Nobody believes cards cause Christmas; both are set by the calendar, and cards come first because people anticipate Christmas. Anticipation is a major source of spurious Granger causality in economics and business: stock prices move before announced earnings because investors anticipate earnings; advertising rises before peak season because companies anticipate the peak. Similarly, a third variable that affects two series with different lags makes the faster-reacting series look as if it "causes" the slower one.
6.2. Stringent conditions
A Granger causality test is only convincing when a series of conditions holds (Haughton et al., 2026). Table 2 lists them and what happens when they are violated.
The conditions in Table 2 rarely hold together. That is why Shojaie and Fox (2022), in their review of Granger causality, conclude that while the concept is limited and generally not informative about causal effects, it can yield useful insights into interactions among variables observed over time. That is also how it should be used in business: as an exploratory tool for forming hypotheses and choosing where to experiment, not as final evidence for an investment decision. Newer methods for causal inference on time series, such as causal discovery algorithms that account for lags, are developing quickly but rest on similar assumptions.
Conclusion
Time series are the data companies have most of and the data most likely to mislead. Two trending series will correlate even when unrelated, like Ohio beavers and Irish GDP, so the first steps are always to plot the series, test stationarity and deal with the trend. When a causal assumption already exists, such as price affecting sales, estimation must still handle inflation, autocorrelation, slow adjustment and especially endogeneity, which can bias every figure however good the fit.
Granger causality answers a narrower question: does the past of one series help forecast another? Six steps, from plotting to impulse responses, give a clear procedure, and applications such as marketing and profit or competitor reactions show it can be useful. But coming first is not causing; anticipation and omitted variables both generate spurious Granger causality. The wise use is to treat the result as a clue about where to experiment, then verify with a stronger design such as a geographic or time-based randomized test.
References
Granger, C. W. J. (1969). Investigating causal relations by econometric models and cross-spectral methods. Econometrica, 37(3), 424–438. https://doi.org/10.2307/1912791
Haughton, D., Haughton, J., & Lo, V. S. Y. (2026). Cause and effect business analytics and data science. CRC Press. https://doi.org/10.1201/9780429172588
Shojaie, A., & Fox, E. B. (2022). Granger causality: A review and recent advances. Annual Review of Statistics and Its Application, 9, 289–319. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-statistics-040120-010930
Yule, G. U. (1926). Why do we sometimes get nonsense-correlations between time-series? A study in sampling and the nature of time-series. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, 89(1), 1–63. https://doi.org/10.2307/2341482

